Volkswagen opened pre-sales Wednesday for the ID. Polo GTI, the first car in the company’s history to wear the GTI badge on an all-electric drivetrain. Starting at 39,995 euros in Germany, it arrives exactly 50 years after the original Golf GTI rewrote the rules for affordable performance.

A 166 kW (226 PS) front-mounted electric motor delivers 290 Nm of torque instantly, pushing the car to 100 km/h in 6.8 seconds. Top speed is electronically limited to 190 km/h, a figure Volkswagen says was calibrated from customer feedback rather than engineering constraints.

It drives the front wheels, just like every GTI before it. An electronically controlled front axle differential lock manages torque distribution through corners, paired with adaptive DCC sport suspension and progressive steering. Volkswagen clearly wants this car to feel like a GTI before it looks like one.

And it does look like one. The red stripe across the nose, honeycomb grille pattern, 19-inch alloy wheels, split roof edge spoiler, and those three iconic letters stamped on the front, rear, and sills leave little room for ambiguity.

Inside, there are top sport seats with updated tartan upholstery, red contrast stitching, and a red 12 o’clock mark on the steering wheel. The nostalgia play runs deep: a retro display mode renders the digital instruments in the style of a late Mk1 Golf’s gauge cluster, and the media player shows your current track as a cassette tape.

A dedicated GTI driving profile, activated from the steering wheel, sharpens throttle response, steering weight, and damper firmness simultaneously while piping in synthetic GTI sound. Whether that sound earns its keep next to the rasp of a turbocharged four-cylinder is a question only a real road test will answer.

The 52 kWh battery provides up to 431 km of WLTP range. DC fast charging peaks at 105 kW, and Volkswagen claims a flat charging curve that moves the battery from 10 to 80 percent in roughly 24 minutes.

Packaging is where the electric architecture pays immediate dividends over the outgoing combustion Polo GTI. Luggage capacity jumps from 351 liters to 441 liters, expanding to 1,240 liters with the rear seats folded. An optional detachable tow bar supports 75 kg of nose weight, enough for a bike carrier with two e-bikes.

The options list stretches further than you might expect for a car positioned as a sporty hatchback. A panoramic glass sunroof, 12-way electrically adjustable front seats with pneumatic massage, a 425-watt Harman Kardon audio system, and a purpose-built 19-inch sport tire are all available. So is the latest generation of Connected Travel Assist, which handles lateral and longitudinal guidance within system limits and can detect red traffic lights.

At just under 40,000 euros, the ID. Polo GTI lands in awkward territory. It undercuts the current Golf GTI by a healthy margin but asks buyers to accept an electric drivetrain in a segment that has always been defined by engine character. Volkswagen is betting that instant torque and zero-delay throttle response can replace exhaust note and a manual gearbox as the core of the GTI experience.

Fifty years of accumulated goodwill is a powerful thing. But goodwill doesn’t survive a car that fails to deliver the visceral kick its badge promises. The order books are open. The verdict is not.